5 Common Mistakes That Are Raising Your Car Insurance Rates And How to Avoid Them

If your car insurance premiums feel unusually high, you’re not alone—and you might be making costly mistakes without even realizing it. Many drivers unknowingly drive their rates up through small, avoidable decisions. Let’s break down the five most common errors that could be hitting your wallet hard and how to fix them.

article image

1. Letting Your Coverage Lapse

Even a short gap in your insurance coverage can label you a high-risk driver. Insurers see this as irresponsible and often increase your rates when you reapply.

How to Avoid It:

Set reminders for policy renewal and consider setting up automatic payments or notifications with your provider.

2. Choosing the Wrong Deductible

Opting for a very low deductible might sound safe, but it usually means much higher monthly premiums.

How to Avoid It:

Balance your deductible based on your driving habits and emergency fund. A slightly higher deductible can reduce your premium significantly.

3. Not Shopping Around for Better Rates

Loyalty doesn’t always pay in the insurance world. If you stick with one company year after year, you may miss out on lower premiums elsewhere.

How to Avoid It:

Get quotes from at least three insurers annually and consider bundling policies (like home and auto) for discounts.

4. Ignoring Your Credit Score

Yes—your credit score can impact your insurance rate in most states. A poor score can make your premiums skyrocket.

How to Avoid It:

Check your credit report regularly and work on paying down debt. Even small improvements in your score can mean savings.

5. Filing Small Claims Too Often

Frequent small claims can make you look risky, even if the claims are legitimate.

How to Avoid It:

Pay out of pocket for minor damage if it’s close to your deductible, especially if it’s a one-time issue.

Conclusion

Avoiding these five mistakes can lead to real savings over time. Take control of your car insurance costs by reviewing your habits, coverage, and provider regularly. A few smart changes can keep more money in your pocket—and still keep you protected.